remove advertisements

LIT BLOG Books/News/Reviews
posthumouser


Age: 63
Sex: F
Location: in the library
Country: Canada

diary contents
diary notes
diarist profile
entry calendar
tag index
gift subscription


Find a Diary


Interests
Academia
Akira Kurosawa
Alzheimer's Research
Animal Behaviour
Animals
Art
Asian Cultural Heritage
Atlases
Aunts and Uncles
Aurora Borealis
Australia
Autodidacts
Banned Books
Barnes and Noble
Book Reviews
Book Slut
Bookcrossers
Books
Bookstores
Canada
Canadian
Canadian Comedy
Card Games
Cemeteries / Graveyards
Cherry Blossom
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome
Chronic Pain
Cirque du Soleil
Civil Rights
Classic Literature
Collages
Comedians
Comedy and Humor Writing
Correct Syntax
Creative Writing
Creativity
Crossword Puzzles
Cuba
Curious George
Cynthia Ozick
Daisies
Dandelions
Darkness
Deep Thought
Depression
Diaries
Dogs
Dolls Houses
Dr. Seuss
Dragonflies
e.e. cummings
Eats Shoots & Leaves
eBay
Eclectic Taste
Editing
Elephants
Empathy
English Bull Terriers
Farm Animals
Fibromyalgia and CFS
Fiction Writing
Fiddler On The Roof
Film
Finland
France
Frangipanis
Funny Words
German
Germany
Green Tea ice cream
Haiku
Hawaii
Historical Fiction
History
Holocaust
Human Rights
Impressionism
Japan
Jewish
Journaling
Journals
Language
Librarians
Libraries
Literature
Literature Lover
Mental Health
Movies
Mysteries
Organ Transplants
Poetry
Prose and Poetry
Psychological Thrillers
Psychology
Public Diary, All Notes
Rain
Random Acts of Kindness
Reading
Religious Freedom
Shakespeare

Bookmarks
!Sophie!
.:.Surveyness.:.
.Tragedy.In.Waiting.
~*whenwedance*~
A Dark Angel's Storm
A Rather Shady Mogwi
Acceber
Agent M
Aging Gracefully
Akeru
allmah
andromeda
Anton
Arbi
Astellus
Autumn's Child
babymade2
BeakerUK
BecomingNurseAmy
BellaDolce
Belle Dame
Bluefish
Book Keeper
booksandmore
bookwormsdiary
Boxer
bumble
Caenis.
caffeinequeen
CelticRose
CherryBoomer
Clanky
Complicated Disaster
ContempoReviews
cookiepuss
Crossman
Cruz Azul
crystal butterfly
CyclingChick
darcy0207
Deve
edna million
Elbereth Gilthoniel
Fire and Ice
Fourth Row
Foxie 2
Frankly.
Garnet & Carnations
Ginger Rogers
glasses eater
gray tabby
Green Goddess
gypsy`immobile
H. Majesty T. Mudfish Queen
Happy Trails
haredawg
Homebody Bookworm
Iconoclasm
Ima Rose
IntentionPositive
invisible.ink
itsjennywrenagain
Jaiyen
jamez
Jennifer*Shane
Joanna Maguire
Journeyman
julieannie
KateD
Krudita
ladylovestheocean
leadingtarget
Lepus
lizan225
loofrin
Lucy Star
ma'am
Mama Blue
Maplelover55
Mokey
mooch
MorLeigh
Mr. Alphabet
mrsLicky
MsJess
Ometeotl
Open Diary
Orange Sorbet
Patrisha
pb reader
Peppermint.
Periwinkle Blue
Peter_24601
phi_
Phoenix Seraph
Picasso
Please Remember
Pooh Bear Granny
Prairie Winds
Principassa Pollyana
Railroadmom
Reel Mama Monkey
RiQuita
roseyrays
Ruby Little
Saz Comp
seedys
Solitude
Spinster
sprimrosesm
Sprog
Sue Happy
SueBSingin
Surviving Life
SymphonyOfSilence
TattooedAngst
temmahkrik
The DiaryMaster
The Pied Pippette
The Thin White Duke
The_Blind_Archer
Themis.
Tiger
torg
VetMom5
williamthebloody
woman in the moon
XOXO
xxfibeexx

THE STORY OF EDGAR SAWTELLE Friday, September 19, 2008

 

The Story of Edgar Sawtelle
 

Fiction, hardcover 562 pgs.

Bond Street Books


This is in many ways a 'boy and his dog story' but I don't think anyone has ever plumbed the emotional depths of dogs in their relatioship to humans in a novel. In doing so of course he has also shown us aspects of human nature we don't see articulated every day either. Wroblewski writing is very good.

A young couple carries on the family business of dog breeding and training in the Wisconsin countryside. Afters years of difficulty Gar and Judy Sawtelle have a beloved baby boy who's perfect but mute. With no medical explanation they resign themselves to teaching him sign language. Edgar is as serious about the dog business as father and grandfather before him. He enjoys perusing the old breeding records and his grandfather's letters about the business. At fourteen he is finally allowed to train the puppies, which he does with hand signals, and he's thrilled. But his father's brother arrives suddenly after years away from the family business and there is an ongoing tension between his father Gar and his uncle Claude that Edgar doesn't like or understand. Tragedy follows and Edgar is the only one who figures out who was responsible. In his frustration of trying to make his mother understand him, Edgar accidently causes a death and decides to run away until things blow over. He spends some weeks wandering with three of his favourite dogs while avoiding people, though he does take up for a while with a man willing to ask no questions of a mute runaway. His loneliness eventually drives him to return home where conflict is inevitable. A killer has to be faced down.

The tension is palpable at this point in the story and the writer knows how to ratchet it up a few notches. Confrontation ensues, first with an old family friend who has suspicions about what's going on. Then with his uncle Claude who has figured out that Edgar knows he's responsible for his father's death and is desperate to hide the evidence. Edgar's emotional state is well laid out for us from the beginning, through his actions and his often furious signing. The author is good at making us feel the boy's frustration when he is not understood or taken serious by adults. But the resolution will still take you by surprise. This is not simply a 'coming of age' story or a mystery/suspense either. This is adult fiction with a powerful emotional impact. As novels go today, it's one of a kind and you won't want to miss it. Four and a half stars out of five.

* If you're like me and don't like to know too much about a story before you read it, avoid reading detailed reviews and don't even read the blurbs on the cover. I call them "blabs" and have trained myself not to read them. Some of them give away too much for my liking.

Okay readers, have you read it? Are you going to? Is it on your wishlist? What are you currently reading? What are you going to read next?

What would you like to see reviewed? If it's on my Coming Reviews list in the sidebar or in my library I would be happy to oblige.

Don't forget to enter my giveaway for Midwife of the Blue Ridge by Christine Blevins which is open worldwide and ends midnight Sunday, September 21,2008 here:

 http://freshinkbooks.blogspot.com/

Updated on Friday September 19:

It was announced today that this is Oprah's new Book Club Pick.  Reserve your copy at the library before everyone else does.




 [Spider Boy] 9/20/2008 12:01:47 AM
I only read girl and a her dog book. Or girl and her cat books Girl and her horse books too

Reading Watch your mouth By Daniel Handler

Appropriate Authors name for all of the above [Joanna Maguire]

9/20/2008 1:38:55 AM
I have my nighttable full of books that are interesting but I just don't have the energy to read them. Did finish Real World a few days ago. Have no idea which one of the ones I'm reading I'll finish next (or pick up again!) Its a situation. [Fire and Ice] 9/20/2008 5:35:14 AM
I think I remember you saying you don't like these kind of books, but I'm reading the Stephanie Plum series by Janet Evanovich. They are soo hilarious. I have laughed my self silly through the first three series almost on the fourth. Before that I've read part of the Twilight Series (b/c it was going to be a movie), and got a headache from it so had to take a break.  [Holli] 9/20/2008 7:40:00 AM
.....BOOOORRRRING.  9/20/2008 1:13:35 PM
I recently finished "Unthinkable" by Amanda Ripley, non-fiction. It's about human psychology in disaster situations. I was surprised by some of the findings and it was a very interesting read. Even though it is about disasters, it made me feel more calm and in control about what I might do if the 'unthinkable' did take place. It's informative, and easy to read. It's a book for everyone. [Homebody Bookworm] 9/22/2008 11:51:10 AM
This was left as a private note. I do not tolerate private notes unless are about something personal. Have the courage of your convictions people.

"In your above entry you claim to not like to read too much about a book before actually reading the book. But I just read this entry and I personally think you've told waaaaaaaaaay too much about the book.

It sounds amazing. But damn. I can guess now what happened and what might have happened in the end. Anyone who reads avidly should be able to just from what you wrote.

So shame shame.

It is my opinion that blurbs are WONDERFUL. BUT they are often written in a way that makes the book sound less interesting that it actually is so I always keep that in mind when reading what you call the "blabs".

I will have to visit your diary more often. [H. M. T. Mudfish Queen] [p]"

After you've read the book darling, you can come back and apologize-in private if you like.

 [posthumouser]

9/26/2008 12:17:46 PM
Its already on my hold list at the library. Thanks to the heads up from you. Where are you?  [Spinster] 10/4/2008 12:58:46 PM
 [JournalThoughts] 11/15/2008 10:16:42 PM
return to top
site map  -  advertise with us  -  privacy policy  -  dedicated hosting by VIA USA  -  contact us
Site design and software © 1998-2011 Open Diary. All rights reserved. OD release 6.0

remove advertisements