Right, I’m sure you all have a voyeuristic side and there’s no way I’m going to write anything coherent about anything but Heather right now, so here’s a simple copy and paste job. I think just because I’m dying for someone to read this and respond to it and I don’t know when Heather will get a chance to.
Dear Heather,
I don’t know how long it will be before you read this e-mail, but here goes.
I’m going to try to be frank, fairly or unfairly. I admit, right now, I feel like you’ve abandoned me. My gut instinct is to want to abandon you back, but that doesn’t work very well seeing as you’re already well into the process of moving on from me, and the idea of “abandoning you back” is childish (if natural) anyway.
I know that telling you this is in a sense counterproductive, because you’re living a very happy life right now and when I say things like “I feel like you’ve abandoned me” obviously it’s going to make you feel bad about yourself which is going to make you unhappy . . . and then your natural response is going to be to avoid the source of your unhappiness, which is me. I don’t want to be the thing that is bringing you down in your life – I feel like I’ve already filled that role enough. I’m sorry that this is all hard for me. I didn’t expect all of this to happen so soon. I think you forget that it was me you were kissing 4 months ago. And things evolved quickly from an unrequited crush on a boy to a full-fledged relationship, from my perspective.
At any rate, you don’t make things worse by talking to me about your relationship with Thomas (if anything, the thing I’m probably most sad about is the fact that I hardly ever talk to you). I mean, honestly, if I’m hurting, I’m hurting over what’s happening, not you telling me about it – and if we’re going to remain friends at all then I think I’m going to figure out what’s happening with you and Thomas sooner or later, hah. I don’t want you to hold back with me or feel like you need to. Certainly don’t do it because you’re trying to be good to me or nice to me. It isn’t benefiting either of us, and I really enjoy hearing how things are going in your life still (and hopefully you still enjoy telling me).
I will ask this of you: Don’t judge me for the route I take with my life from here on out. Right now your absence has left a void in my life, and I feel like I may have to meet it in ways that I don’t necessarily think are ideal, but may be the only solution to getting past this. Understand, I’m not trying to place blame on you for anything – any actions I take are my choice and I take full responsibility for them. I don’t believe that you have treated me poorly in any way and I still don’t begrudge you for anything. You’ve been good to me, Heather. But I have reached a point in my life where I am simply unhappy and feel very alone. I have to satisfy the needs that I have in some way or things aren’t going to get better. Just remember that, no matter what, I’m still the same Matt, even if I do change a little.
I feel like I’m writing you a goodbye letter, and I don’t want to be. But I think the fact is what I’m writing is turning into a goodbye letter because you’re already gone and I’m trying to get a proper goodbye in before you forget about me and what we were. I know how easy it is to get wrapped up in the present and that 4 months was an eternity ago for you, nevermind 16 months ago. But don’t forget about what we had and what a special person you were and always will be to me. I honestly don’t believe I will ever have a relationship anything like the one you and I had ever again. And, again, I know how easy it is to get caught up in the present relationship and how quickly memories fade. But the two of us had something very unique, something that you or I will probably never experience again exactly, since we’re unlikely to come across such a special set of circumstances again or a person who fits us in that same way again. I don’t know the course your life is going to take from this point forward, but I am willing to bet there will be rough points along the way when things aren’t as glorious as they are now. Know that I will be here when that time comes – I don’t mean that in a cheesy romantic sense. I only mean to say, even if this is turning into a bit of a goodbye letter, it isn’t intended to be a go away letter. I still love you and I’m always here for you.
Please, more than anything, don’t remember me or my relationship with you with sadness. Our relationship has been so volatile for so long, that sometimes I think we lose sight of the good times that we really had together. So, when you think of me, think of pogo sticks and Sorry, think of endless laughter and big hugs, think of how our feelings matured and evolved, and think of how much I loved you and how much you loved me.
And, hey, just remember to think of me sometimes.
Still,
<span style="FONT-SIZE: 1
0pt”>Matt
Oh, Matt. This made me cry. Are you happy now?? This was very beautiful and articulate and I think covered as much skin as you could. I think her response, if she is an understanding sort, will be favorable. Private because I feel weird that Heather might read a note about a letter to her… xoxoxox
Warning Comment
I’ve written letters like this one but was never ballsy enough to actually send them, which makes me wonder what would have happened if I did. And if you actually did send this to her, good for you. If she’s as special as you’ve written, I think she’ll appreciate it.
Warning Comment
Did you send it?
Warning Comment
Yeah, I sent the e-mail, and Heather can read this diary anyway, so . . .
Warning Comment
That is a very well-written e-mail. I hope she takes it well.
Warning Comment
Sorry, I don’t like it. You say ‘but’ so many times after you make good points that it almost seems like you ARE trying to make her unhappy. I think most of it was good, it just kind of seemed like you were reminding her of how great you guys were so that she’d come back. Anyway, you probably don’t want to read this kind of note, but maybe that’s Karma? ~I’ll be
Warning Comment
It’s really hard when they’ve moved on and you’re still stuck, hopelessly in love with them. In my situation, Sandy told me that it’s impossible to go from being lovers to friends right off the bat, and that she couldn’t be friends with me anymore. I think that’s what hurts most of all, losing the best friend I ever had. She and Heather are like two peas in a pod. They’ve found new loves and ..
Warning Comment
moved on and you and I (well, at least I am) trying to wonder if she loved me all that much after all if she could move on so quickly and forget me. See? I’ve been feeling really sorry for myself lately. Sorry, I’ve just dumped this all over you now. For my part, I’ve been too afraid to send an email like this to Sandy for fear she’ll just laugh at me.
Warning Comment
I felt it was honest and open and I love that. I wish when I hurt somebody they told me in the way you are telling her. I hate not knowing how people feel and I think she is willing to understand how you feel and to actually care about your feelings.
Warning Comment
Of course she remembers and values the relationship: she’s a girl, that’s what we do. ~I’ll be
Warning Comment
I’m sorry for leaving early. I was feeling like crap and all I wanted to do was sleep. Which I couldn’t fall asleep anyway and am back online, so it was pointless in the end. But again… sorry.
Warning Comment
I have to agree with I’ll Be.. it does sound like your trying to make her unhappy. If her moving on from you didnt bother you this letter would not be needed. I can understand that you really care about her and love her. And she was your first true love or love of your life. something to that nature. Thats y they call it first cause there is a second and a third. Youll meet some1. take care
Warning Comment
I wasn’t trying to make anyone unhappy. Just trying to be honest. Sure things would be better if I just didn’t say anything, though.
Warning Comment
Sometimes I really wonder how hard a relationship’s going to actually hit you when you have one with someone who’s there. It is just so infinitely fiercer and messier than this distanced stuff. I mean aren’t we all online because it’s protected, detached? And then other times I wonder: would you never want one, for that reason? Am not trying to dig. In no position to.
Warning Comment
I liked the letter, Matt. I think it was extremely honest and very “you” and I think saying all of these things is something you have to do. So, I’m glad you got to say them. I disagree with some of the other things people have said here. Basically, I think Heather will see your intentions and I think she’ll see everything you’re trying to say. And, I don’t think Heather will ever forget you or
Warning Comment
the amazing connection and relationship that the two of you shared. I know you’re afraid of that, but you can never ever forget the person you loved and cared about. Trust me. I know. Besides, you’re pretty hard to forget with your love of goats and all… HA! Made you smile.
Warning Comment
I agree with Michael. I agree with a lot of things said here. See your inbox in an hour.
Warning Comment
Oh Matty. I hope you are both okay in the end of all of this. I can certainly understand the amount of work it took to write that, much more to send it. What changes are you talking about? What are you planning on doing? I love you, Matty. I mean that.
Warning Comment