Stupid Question

Did ancient people work out?   I mean… did they really have the massive bulging muscles that you see in Troy and 300?  

yes, i know this isn't 300 or troy. shut up.

Yeah, yeah, I know their lifestyles would require more manual labour and lifting and stuff, so they’d do more incidental exercise.  Well, some of them would anyway – some of those guys, even those in the army, would get servants to do everything.  You’re going to tell me that King Leonidas would do the plowing himself?  

My brothers are quite muscular, and to get that way they have weights at home and they constantly work out – and then they consume vast quantities of whey protein and knock heads together and do chin-ups and stuff like that.

In days of yore, the Jones would work in warehouses as a storeman or even forklift driver.  So that’s plenty of manual labour and heavy lifting.  However, he didn’t work out or eat lots of protein.  He didn’t really eat anything much. Hence, he was a skinny bloke with well-toned yet modestly sized upper arm muscles and absolutely nothing else muscular about him.  This is my counter-example to show that to get really big guns, you have to try specifically for that.

Yes, I know it’s obvious that a movie is a fiction, but I was just wondering if they could have muscles like that before the invention gyms and creatine and photoshop.  Or wait… they had gyms, didn’t they?  Shit, I don’t know.  That’s why I want to brush up on this aspect of history.

Muscles are impressive if you’re the strong guy in the circus.  Otherwise I find lean, dare I say even skinny guys more attractive.  They’re also easier to arm wrestle and to domestically abuse – it’s important when you’re objectifying someone that their body type doesn’t prevent you from slapping them around a bit or proving your superior strength in some kind of physical challenge, so that’s what I go for.

Otherwise, really muscular people just look to me like the following:

PROTIP:  Don’t google image search "Troy muscles" or "Troy movie muscles" without safe search set to at least "moderate" while at work.  Just… trust me.  Same thing goes for "lumberjack".

Log in to write a note
January 20, 2009

Um, I don’t think most of them looked like that. Thanks for taking what I said the right way. We do have control over our lives, our actions.

January 21, 2009

*averts eyes* I heard somewhere that the men who build muscle like those in 300 aren’t that strong. It’s the “fat” looking guys that could hurl a dump truck across a field.

January 21, 2009

Ryn: Erm, yeah. Got a little bit better, thanks for dropping by and asking. 🙂 Tried lumberjack… *nod* I see what you mean.

etier way old men to debbie girls thay all ned to put the cells down and drive

January 28, 2009

I’d imagine a massive intake of protein would be needed to build those kinds of muscles. It’d have to be pretty intentional. Also, I’m assuming meat was a bit more a rarity depending on time, region, and status.

March 10, 2009

300 guys. 30 million abs.