American Idol: The Girls, As I Heard It.

Oh no, how did I forget to record American idol tonight????  Grrrrrr.  So I watched on my computer, even though it sounded tinny.  Not the best way to hear but that’s the way it goes.
 
Ok . . .
 
Asia’h — Dance with Somebody — She sounded good.  It seemed fine.  Nothing extraordinary.  — Ok, saw the recap and she sounded a whole lot better than on my computer.
 
Kady — Who Wants to Live Forever — She seemed like she was slightly above some of the notes.  Not her worst performance, but she’s not terribly appealing for a pretty girl.  — On the recap, it doesn’t sound like it went too well.
 
Kristy Lee — Faithfully — It was fine.  Nothing exciting there either.  It sounded like she went a little out of control at the end, but that could be my computer sound.
 
Amanda — I Hate Myself for Loving You — She sounded ok for what she does,but this isn’t the right show for her.  — The recap clip sounded pretty good.
 
Carly – I Drove All Night — It sounded like it was well sung.  Not one of my favorite songs, but I think she sounded ok.
 
Ramiele — Against All Odds — I really like this song, and I can’t fault her voice, but it seemed very 80s.  I wonder if her sexy pictures scandal has sapped some of her confidence?   
 
All right, at least I have these two recorded so I can actually hear them —
 
Brooke — Love Is a Battlefield — I liked her take on it.  I like her.
 
Syesha — Saving All My Love — is she nervous tonight?  This seemed like a weak performance for her.  I think it wasn’t the best song choice for her.  I was disappointed in her tonight.
 
Ok, I really only got a good chance to hear the last two and I liked Brooke.
 
Who should go home, based on my tinny computer sounds?   Kady.  And Amanda. 
 
So what did you all think?